Welcome to Uptown Pizza
Your Local Pizza Restaurant
in St. Augustine, FL
If you’ve lived in St. Augustine for a while — or even just visited a few times — there’s a good chance you’ve heard of our little corner spot on San Marco Ave. What you might not know is that Uptown Pizza isn’t just a restaurant. We’re a local gathering place, a neighborhood staple, and a proud part of the vibrant St. Augustine community. What started as the city’s very first modern gas station eventually transformed into a fruit stand and, ultimately, a beloved pizzeria with deep roots and a lot of heart.
Today, we carry forward that same dedication to quality, flavor, and good times. From our brick ovens to our relaxed beer and wine garden, everything we do is meant to bring people together for a shared love of great food and great company.
Featured Reviews
Amazing Food! Delicious Pizza, delicious Calzone, delicious wings!!! Great and friendly service. Don’t get discouraged by wait times, food is worth it just be patient!
– Jazmin Figueroa
We got the margarita 10” pizza and the Chicken Bacon Pesto Sub. The pizza was amazing, so cheesy and tasty. The pesto sub was delicious!
The service was quick and easy, didn’t have to wait long.
– Prerana Cshekar
Nicely located, easy walk from our hotel. Ordered wings and a margarita pizza for take out. Never had a margarita pizza with only a white/ricotta base so that was different but everything taste great
– P
St. Augustine Pizza That’s a Cut Above
Here in the Nation’s Oldest City, we’ve got history on every corner — and we’re proud to be a part of it. But our real legacy is all about the food. When it comes to St. Augustine pizza, Uptown Pizza stands apart because we never take shortcuts, and definitely no compromises. We prepare every order fresh, using brick ovens that bring out the best in every ingredient.
Our secret? It’s no secret at all. We keep it simple and authentic. Whether you’re enjoying a slice under the Florida sun or tucking into a whole pie with friends on a cooler coastal evening, the difference is in the details—and you can taste it.
More Than Pizza
A Full Family Menu
Uptown Pizza is a family restaurant in St. Augustine, FL, and we mean that in every sense. Whether you’re stopping by after a beach day at Anastasia State Park, looking for a casual night out with the kids, or grabbing a dinner after a ghost tour, we’ve got something on the menu for everyone.
Of course, we’ve got the classics—New York-style pizza, calzones, strombolis — but we also serve up hot and cold subs stacked with premium ingredients, hearty pasta dinners, crisp salads, and appetizers worth sharing (or not, we don’t judge). There’s even a kid’s menu, because we know that little foodies need something just for them.
And for those days when you’re not dining in? Our catering services bring that same flavor-packed experience to your next family party, office lunch, or event. We’ve even started welcoming bus tours, so if you’re bringing a group through the heart of St. Augustine, we’ve got room — and flavor — for everyone.
A Place to Eat, A Place to Hang Out
Food might bring people in, but it’s the atmosphere that keeps them coming back. At Uptown Pizza, we’ve created more than just a restaurant—we’ve created a community hangout. Our beer and wine garden is the perfect spot to kick back with friends and enjoy a drink in the breeze. The laid-back charm of St. Augustine shines through here, where conversations flow as easily as the wine, and music always fills the air.
Speaking of music, we love our live events. From weekly trivia nights to karaoke that brings out local talent, there’s always something going on. We’ve hosted Battle of the Bands competitions, Halloween festivals, and even full-on carnivals. These aren’t just events—they’re community envolvment we’re proud to build with our neighbors. And the best part? We’ve got our own parking lot, which — as any St. Augustine local knows—is a true rarity and a serious convenience.
Local Flavor, Local Love
Uptown Pizza is proud to be part of the St. Augustine scene, where palm trees sway in the breeze, the Matanzas River sparkles, and the energy of downtown blends with the calm of the beaches. We see familiar faces all the time — folks heading home from the Alligator Farm, locals just off a shift at Flagler Hospital, or families riding bikes back from Salt Run. We’re more than just a stop on the way—we’re a destination in our own right.
Being a family restaurant in St. Augustine, FL, means we take care of our community. Whether it’s welcoming tourists with genuine hospitality, or simply knowing your regular order when you walk in — we treat everyone like family here.
Areas Served
Jacksonville, FL | Palm Coast, FL | World Golf Village, FL | Fruit Cove, FL | Ponte Vedra Beach, FL | Vilano Beach, FL | Hastings, FL | Crescent Beach, FL | Marineland, FL | Elkton, FL
Visit Uptown Pizza Today
So whether you’re craving the best St. Augustine pizza around, looking for a place the whole family can enjoy, or just want to grab a cold beer and catch some live music, we’re here to welcome you. From the smell of our freshly baked pies to the buzz of laughter coming from the beer garden, there’s something special about this place — and we’d love to share it with you. Come see what makes Uptown Pizza more than just a meal — it’s a whole experience that reflects the warmth, charm, and flavor of St. Augustine itself. We can’t wait to meet you.
Your New Favorite Spot in the Nation’s Oldest City
Here at Uptown Pizza, we’re proud of where we come from and even more excited about where we’re going. Every dish we serve is a reflection of the community we love and the traditions we carry forward. And with authentic ingredients, a welcoming local vibe, and an event lineup that brings people together, we’re not just another pizza place — we’re a neighborhood tradition in the making. So the next time you’re strolling through St. Augustine or looking for a new go-to dinner spot, swing by. We’ll have a seat ready, a pie in the oven, and the kind of welcoming spirit that feels like home. Let’s make your next meal one to remember.