icon 904 829 1133
Pizza, Sandwich, Drinks, and More

Best Pizza in Town

ONLINE ORDER
VIEW MENU
not found

THE ART OF PIZZA

Borrillo's Pizza & Subs

Borrillo's occupies a charming spot that was initially St. Augustine's first modern Pure gas station. Over the years, it transformed into a fruit stand before becoming the Borrillo's Pizza and Subs we know today. Scott Borrillo, the original creator, had an extraordinary talent and passion for pizza, setting a high bar from the beginning.

Experience
More Than 10 Years
Phone
904 829 1133
About Us View Menu
Choose the Best

Recommended Menu

icon
icon
Appetizers

View Menu
icon
Hot & Cold Subs

View Menu
icon
Pasta Plates

View Menu
icon
icon
Calzone & Stromboli

View Menu
Beautiful Experiences

Our Gallery

Great spot for lunch! Real New York style pizza. You can order pizza by the slice. They have huge slices and they’re delicious! The photo I took was a slice we cut in half. This place has quick service and booth style seating. Atmosphere is laid back and casual. Highly recommend their pizza!

Mark Goujon

Stopped by shortly before closing on a Friday night hoping we weren’t too late to order a pie. At first we were told the kitchen was closed, but they took mercy on us and said they’d make one last order. The staff and owners were friendly and welcoming.

Bobbi Becker

Our experience was 5 stars! We sat outside and listened to a good little band that played my favorites so things started out just right. I’m a bit if a pizza snob and the margarita pizza was delicious. The crust was perfect and the basil and tomatoes were fresh.

Gina Capriotti

After driving around for about an hour looking for a water-front seafood restaurant, we came here, because the wait times were too long at the seafood options. We were expecting Borrillo's to be somewhat of a let down, especially since we eat plenty of quality pizza in New York.

Johan Steiner
100% authentic ingredients

Visit Our Place

We pride ourselves on quality and authenticity, which is why we forgo microwaves, range tops, and heat warmers. Everything is cooked to perfection in our imported Italian brick ovens, a cornerstone of our culinary process. Our sauce, made from San Marzano tomatoes, along with bufala mozzarella and Prosciutto di Parma, adds unparalleled flavor to our pizzas.

Book a Table

    Click here
    Click here

    This is the heading

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipiscing elit dolor
    Click Here
    Click here

    This is the heading

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipiscing elit dolor
    Click Here