Pizza and Subs in St. Augustine, FL
Discover Your New Favorite Pizza
If you’re a local here in St. Augustine — or even just a frequent visitor who knows the best places to eat — chances are you’ve heard whispers of a little gem just across the Bridge of Lions. That gem is us: Uptown Pizza. We’ve taken a historic slice of St. Augustine (literally the site of the city’s first modern gas station) and turned it into something more than just a restaurant. We’ve built a place where pizza meets personality, and where great food, laughter, and local charm all come together under one roof—or out in the beer and wine garden when the Florida sun is shining.
From our hand-tossed brick oven pizzas to hot and cold subs piled high with premium ingredients, everything our pizza restaurant does is rooted in quality, tradition, and a deep love for our city.
Dine, Relax, and Stay Awhile
We’re not just a takeout spot — though we’re great for that, too. At Uptown Pizza, we’ve created a space where you can slow down and enjoy the moment. Our beer and wine garden is a favorite among locals for a reason. It’s the perfect place to unwind, whether you’re sharing a pizza with friends, catching live music, belting out karaoke, or enjoying one of our many community events like trivia night or the ever-popular Battle of the Bands.
We even host seasonal events like our Halloween Festival and Carnival, turning our space into a true neighborhood hub. And if you’re trying to avoid downtown parking headaches, don’t worry — we’ve got our own lot, which around here is a pretty big deal.
Brick Oven Pizza with a Local Twist
When we say “gourmet pizza in St. Augustine, FL,” we’re not just talking about fancy toppings — we’re talking about flavor that tells a story. All of our pizzas are made to order and cooked in authentic brick ovens, with no shortcuts in sight. We use beautiful ingredients because we believe every pizza should be an experience. You can build your own with your favorite toppings or choose from one of our local favorites:
- Cheese – pizza sauce and shredded mozzarella
- Margherita – pizza sauce, basil, fresh mozzarella, olive oil
- Carnivore – pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham
- Garden – pizza sauce, cheese, spinach, mushroom, onion, pepper, olive and tomato
- Supremo – pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, pepper, olive, mushroom
- Bianca – shredded mozzarella, ricotta, olive oil
- Hot Chick – grilled chicken and mozzarella, garnished with hot sauce, a ranch drizzle, and parsley
- The Barbie – grilled chicken, mozzarella and red onion, garnished with barbecue sauce and parsley
- El Cubano – shredded mozzarella, swiss cheese, ham, pulled pork, pickles, garnished with honey mustard and parsley
- Steak Pizza – a light portion of shredded mozzarella, sliced ribeye, diced onions and American cheese, garnished with lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar
Pizza Creation
- Peperoni, Ham, Green Peppers, Jalapenos
- Sausage, Salami, Kalamata Olives, Banana Peppers
- Bacon, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Pineapple
- Meatball, Onions, Basil, Ricotta
- Chicken, Black Olives, Garlic, Pickles
Prefer a gluten-free base? You can swap for our 10” cauliflower crust. Want to mix it up? Switch out your base for Alfredo, pesto, or our honey cilantro mustard for just a couple bucks more. Add hot agave or balsamic glaze for a sweet and tangy finishing touch. And yes, we know — great pizza takes time. So please allow 30 minutes or more during busy times. Trust us, it’s worth the wait.
Hot & Cold Subs to Satisfy Every Appetite
Not in a pizza mood? No worries. We’re just as serious about our subs. Whether you want something classic or something stacked and sizzling, we’ve got you covered.
Hot Subs
- Cuban – honey mustard, ham, pulled pork, swiss, pickles
- Philly Cheesesteak – Shaved Steak with sauteed onions and American cheese
- Hero – Shaved Steak with Peperoni, Salami and Banana Peppers and American cheese
- Meatball Parmigiana – meatball, sauce, parmigiana and mozzarella
- Chicken Parmigiana – chicken cutlet, parmigiana and mozzarella
- Meatball a la Vodka – meatball parm utilizing a rosa cream sauce
- Chicken a la Vodka – chicken parm utilizing a rosa cream sauce
- Chicken Alfredo – chicken parm utilizing a white cream sauce
- Chicken Florentine – chicken alfredo with spinach and tomato
Cold Subs
- Ham – ham, cheese, LTO
- Turkey – turkey, cheese, LTO
- Italian – Ham, Salami, and Peperoni, cheese, LTO
You can “Make It Thick” by adding turkey, ham, salami, pepperoni, or bacon, and top it off with provolone, feta, mozzarella, or Swiss cheese. Prefer to keep things light? “Get the Skinny” with banana peppers, jalapeños, tomatoes, green peppers, mushrooms, and olives. And don’t forget to round it out with a drink and a bag of chips — combo it up.
Bringing Flavor to You
Hosting a get-together? We cater! From small parties to full-on bus tours (yes, we welcome those, too), we make it easy to feed a crowd with flavor everyone will remember. Give us a call to plan your next pizza party or group lunch—our team will make sure it goes off without a hitch.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Come Visit Us and Taste What St. Augustine’s Talking About
Uptown Pizza is your new favorite stop if you love good food, friendly faces, and a vibe that’s as warm as the Florida sunshine. Whether you’re in the mood for gourmet pizza in St. Augustine, FL, or just want a satisfying sub after a day at Anastasia State Park, we’ve got the flavor and the atmosphere to make your meal memorable. So stop by, hang out in our garden, grab a cold drink, and let us serve up something special. We look forward to feeding you soon — and hopefully, often.