Reviews

Click here to prove you are human.

craig spahr November 5, 2022
"We're the tourists that like to "eat where the locals go" and always come to this "Diamond" of a restaurant. Great Food, Entertainment and the Beer flows while relaxing on the deck. See your again end of Nov."
Damos Doom November 5, 2022
"Best pizza I had in a long time, we got a Greek pizza with added meats, salami and Italian sausage. We also got a pepperoni calzon and both were delicious if you like pizza this is the place to go for sure. Update, still the best pizza I've had 2 years later"
Damos Doom November 5, 2022
"Best pizza I had in a long time, we got a Greek pizza with added meats, salami and Italian sausage. We also got a pepperoni calzon and both were delicious if you like pizza this is the place to go for sure. Update, still the best pizza I've had 2 years later"
InsaneHarlequin November 3, 2022
"We were in town for our honeymoon and wanted to find a more local feeling pizza place, came here Halloween night and loved it. Staff were super friendly and laid back, pizza was so good we very nearly came back to get some for the road back to Tallahassee. Will be going back the next time we're in town 🍕❤️ also they have their own parking which in st augustine is amazing"
InsaneHarlequin November 3, 2022
"We were in town for our honeymoon and wanted to find a more local feeling pizza place, came here Halloween night and loved it. Staff were super friendly and laid back, pizza was so good we very nearly came back to get some for the road back to Tallahassee. Will be going back the next time we're in town 🍕❤️ also they have their own parking which in st augustine is amazing"
Dawn Byers October 24, 2022
"Wow! What a gem. Our family was in St. Augustine on vacation and wanted some tasty pizza. We walked past Borrillo’s on our way back to our hotel. We ordered the cauliflower crust Margherita pizza, a cheese pizza and pizza knots. DELICIOUS! We were so excited to eat it, we forgot to take pictures. Trust me, this place was awesome!"